11

While reviewing suggested edits I noticed that some users sometimes edit others posts and remove salutations like

[Question text which follows the rules]

...

Thanks!

or

[Question text which follows the rules]

...

Thanks a lot

[Name]

Should we remove salutations? I personally wouldn't like it if somebody else edits my posts like that. At least thanking in advance should be ok in my opinion. Begin polite is also part of a community. I'd suggest to only remove extended salutations, e.g. if they more look like these much-beloved 10 line mail signatures.

What is your take on this?

||||||
11

The rules for stackoverflow apply to magento.SE.
See this for reference.
I read some of the answers (I hope I didn't miss something importan) and my conclusion is salutations are kind of a grey area. They are not encouraged but they are not banned.

Signing your posts...a big NO NO. You shouldn't do that.

||||||
  • 10
    "Signing your posts...a big NO NO. You shouldn't do that." - I completely agree! - Ben Marks, Developer & Community Evangelist, Magento, an eBay Inc Company, MCAB, MCD, MCD+, MCFD, MCSS, Sagittarius, Isle of Palms, SC... – benmarks Feb 12 '15 at 14:55
  • 4
    @benmarks. Sorry the name doesn't ring a bell. Can you give me more info, please? – Marius Feb 12 '15 at 15:02
5

When editing questions, I always remove "fluff" like that, as it is policy on StackOverflow as well, but I wouldn't go so far to edit questions just to remove "Thank you".

What I consider fluff:

  • "thanks"
  • salutation and signing
  • irrelevant information about the poster (like "I am new to Magento")
  • irrelevant information about the problem (like "this is urgent!!!111")

Side note: When reading "Thanks in advance", I always think about the quote:

this connotes an intention not to thank anybody afterwards

||||||
4

"Welcome to Magento.SE!" is a standard I use for first-timers. I think this should be an exception and be allowed.

||||||
  • yup. Me too using this. It should be allowed – Rajeev K Tomy Feb 17 '15 at 4:16
0

Say Hi at first and an anticipated Thanks at the end just make it polite and no disturbance for the following readers.

Signing : Agreed with Marius answer, a big no no, simply because no matter what, the post is signed already, so that becomes redundant...

||||||

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .