11

While reviewing suggested edits I noticed that some users sometimes edit others posts and remove salutations like

[Question text which follows the rules]

...

Thanks!

or

[Question text which follows the rules]

...

Thanks a lot

[Name]

Should we remove salutations? I personally wouldn't like it if somebody else edits my posts like that. At least thanking in advance should be ok in my opinion. Begin polite is also part of a community. I'd suggest to only remove extended salutations, e.g. if they more look like these much-beloved 10 line mail signatures.

What is your take on this?

11

The rules for stackoverflow apply to magento.SE.
See this for reference.
I read some of the answers (I hope I didn't miss something importan) and my conclusion is salutations are kind of a grey area. They are not encouraged but they are not banned.

Signing your posts...a big NO NO. You shouldn't do that.

  • 10
    "Signing your posts...a big NO NO. You shouldn't do that." - I completely agree! - Ben Marks, Developer & Community Evangelist, Magento, an eBay Inc Company, MCAB, MCD, MCD+, MCFD, MCSS, Sagittarius, Isle of Palms, SC... – benmarks Feb 12 '15 at 14:55
  • 4
    @benmarks. Sorry the name doesn't ring a bell. Can you give me more info, please? – Marius Feb 12 '15 at 15:02
5

When editing questions, I always remove "fluff" like that, as it is policy on StackOverflow as well, but I wouldn't go so far to edit questions just to remove "Thank you".

What I consider fluff:

  • "thanks"
  • salutation and signing
  • irrelevant information about the poster (like "I am new to Magento")
  • irrelevant information about the problem (like "this is urgent!!!111")

Side note: When reading "Thanks in advance", I always think about the quote:

this connotes an intention not to thank anybody afterwards

4

"Welcome to Magento.SE!" is a standard I use for first-timers. I think this should be an exception and be allowed.

  • yup. Me too using this. It should be allowed – Rajeev K Tomy Feb 17 '15 at 4:16
0

Say Hi at first and an anticipated Thanks at the end just make it polite and no disturbance for the following readers.

Signing : Agreed with Marius answer, a big no no, simply because no matter what, the post is signed already, so that becomes redundant...

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .